Home

Blog

Our Meiselman Journey: Part 10 – When the Pipes Fail

Our Meiselman Journey: Part 10 – When the Pipes Fail

Drain and vent pipe replacement
November 13, 2026 Rich Jackim
|
6–9 minutes

Off to a Great Start

Construction wrapped up in December 2025, and by March 2026, we were officially open for guests. And honestly? Those first five months were great.

The bookings came in steadily. We had almost reached our annual cap of 26 guest stays.

The reviews came in even better — a dozen five-star ratings and counting, with guests raving about the mid-century details, the pool, the art, and the light.

Susan and I were happy. We were sure we’d made it through the hard part.

We hadn’t.

An Unpleasant Smell and a Big Surprise

The first hint of trouble didn’t come from a guest complaint or a bad review — it came from our property management team. Between a couple of guest stays this summer, the team picked up on something faint but unmistakable: a whiff of sewage in the house. Not overwhelming, not constant, but present enough that they flagged it for us right away rather than brushing it off.

That’s exactly the kind of attentiveness you want from a property manager, and it’s the only reason we caught this before it became a full-blown guest-facing problem. A recurring sewage smell in a 65-year-old home isn’t something to shrug off, especially with new guests cycling through every week. So we called in a local plumber our property manager recommended to investigate.

Smoke and Mirrors (Literally)

The plumber’s diagnostic tool of choice was a smoke test — and if you’ve never seen one, it’s honestly kind of cool. They plug the sewer line, pump non-toxic smoke into it, and then watch to see where that smoke escapes. If your drain and vent system is sealed up tight, as it should be, the smoke stays contained. If it’s not, you get a very clear (and very smelly) roadmap of exactly where things are going wrong.

Ours told us everything we needed to know. Smoke started coming out from the walls in the kitchen and in the primary bath — both spots right below the sinks. Not a subtle leak. Not a “maybe someday” problem. An active, visible failure.

Opening the Walls, Finding the Real Story

Once the plumber started opening up the walls to get a closer look, he ran the smoke test again — and this time the picture got a lot worse. The vent pipe joints had corroded so severely that many were no longer connected.

We’re talking pipes hanging loose, disconnected from the fittings below them, with decades of steel and cast iron simply disintegrating from the inside out.

Given what they found, the plumber’s recommendation was blunt and unambiguous: replace all the drain and vent pipes in the house. Not patch. Not spot-repair. Full replacement.

The Part That Made Us Want to Scream

Here’s where the frustration really set in. Our bathrooms and kitchen were now beautifully finished — new tile, new shower pans, brand-new terrazzo floors. Getting to those failing pipes didn’t mean tearing up all of it, thankfully.

The total cost for the pipe replacement alone: $39,000. And that figure didn’t even include repairing the sections of wall and floor we’d have to open up to get there.

To put that in perspective, that’s essentially one year of revenue for our STR property.

Naturally, our minds went straight to Southwest Plumbing & Fire Protection, the company that had re-piped our house when every wall was already open during our remodel. How did they miss this?

We asked. Before we’d even hired our new plumber, Southwest Plumbing sent someone out to run their own sewage-gas detection test. Their verdict? Everything was fine. They also told us they’d inspected these same drain and vent pipes when the walls were open during the remodel and found them to be in good condition. Really???

That’s a hard claim to square with the videos our plumber sent us — smoke billowing out of open wall cavities, pipes cracked down the middle, pipe joints rusted through and disconnected. We hate to call them liars, but whatever they checked, it wasn’t this.

You don’t have to be a plumber to see that these pipes needed to be replaced. The fact that Southwest Plumbing & Fire Protection claims it inspected these pipes and found them OK five months ago, when the walls were all opened up, is frankly unbelievable and unprofessional.

Our advice: do not use Southwest Plumbing & Fire Protection. Their bad advice and lack of professionalism cost us a fortune, and they weren’t willing to take any responsibility.

Wade Steps Up

If there’s a silver lining here, it was Wade Petrowich of Malbec Builders, our general contractor (contact info below). He originally hired Southwest Plumbing & Fire Protection as he sub contractor to handle the plumbing for our remodel.

To his credit, Wade didn’t dodge the situation — he agreed to cover the cost of restoring the home to its original condition once the plumbing repairs were complete. That meant patching and rematching the tile, removing and reinstalling the cabinets and shower glass, redoing shower pan sections, and fixing the terrazzo flooring wherever the plumbers had to cut in. He agreed to do this at his expense.

But it was no simple task. We had to try to find the original tile if it was still available and match the dye lots as best we could. Unfortunately, we discovered that the tile we used had been discontinued, and there wasn’t enough inventory left to redo both bathrooms. As a result, we had to select new tile and completely redo all of the tile work in the primary bathroom. Wade agreed to do it at no charge.

That is the kind of professionalism and accountability you hope for from a contractor, but don’t always get. We were grateful to have to have Wade on our team.

The Timeline (and the Lost Bookings)

Even with Wade on board to help make things right, this wasn’t a quick or inexpensive fix. The total project to demo the bathrooms, order the tile, and restore the bathrooms took six weeks.

Six weeks during which the home couldn’t host guests.

That meant canceling two guest stays — a hit of nearly $5,000 in lost rental revenue on top of the repair costs. Not the kind of expense that showed up in our original renovation budget.

Drain and vent pipe replacement
Brand new walls and floor torn up to replace corroded drain and vent pipes in an MCM home

Key Takeaways for Your Own Meiselman (or Any MCM) Home

If you own – or are thinking of buying – a vintage Palm Springs home, here’s what this whole ordeal taught us:

If your water supply pipes need replacing, assume your drain and vent pipes do too. These systems are made of the same materials, and in a house this old, it’s safe to assume they are running on borrowed time. Replace both at the same time.

Don’t defer drain and vent work “for later.” It’s tempting to fix what’s visible and leave the rest, especially mid-remodel when budgets are already stretched. But waiting means you’ll eventually be cutting back into finished work — tile, terrazzo, shower pans — to get back in there. That’s a far more expensive way to do the same job.

A clean sewage-gas test isn’t the same as a smoke test. Ours came back “fine” from one method and catastrophically compromised from the other. If you’re diagnosing a smell, ask specifically for a smoke test.

Get a second opinion when the story doesn’t add up. If a contractor tells you something was already checked and found to be fine, and a new professional shows you video evidence to the contrary, trust the video.

Contractor accountability matters. Wade didn’t have to cover the cost of restoring our finished bathrooms — but he did, because his subcontractor’s work (or lack thereof) created the problem. When you’re assembling your renovation team, general contractors who stand behind their subs’ work are worth their weight in gold.

It wasn’t the update we wanted to share about our beautifully finished bathrooms. But if it saves even one fellow MCM owner from the same expensive surprise, it’s worth it.

Did You Know

If you enjoyed this article, did you know that you can actually stay in our house when you’re in Palm Springs? Click here to learn more about our vacation rental options.

Resources

Wade Petrowich
Malbec Builders
wade@malbecbuilders.com
760.625.9977

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *